On November 20, the morning before a scheduled court appearance on child abuse charges, he committed suicide by gunshot. I like your point that case studies should be invested in, they are an valid research method and should continue when the opportunity arrises. A unique opportunity to study a unique individual in great detail. Studies like this have very high ecological validity as there are no variables that have been manipulated. Trying to create these circumstances would be very unethical but naturally observing rare circumstances is progressive. You are commenting using your WordPress. This means that they lack validity as the results cannot be applied to a larger population.
Genie, the feral child who left a mark on researchers”. To date, no one directly involved in Genie’s case has responded to this controversy. Genie’s father disliked children and wanted none of his own, finding them noisy, but around five years into their marriage his wife became pregnant. Her abuse came to the attention of Los Angeles child welfare authorities in November , when she was 13 years and 7 months old. The New York Times.
Although the twins developed to be described as ‘above average’, it is not known how well they may have developed had they not suffered privation, and so it is not known exactly how well the negative effects were reversed. Her mother died in This page was last edited on 22 Mayat Genie spent og next 12 years of her life locked in her bedroom.
Study in Detail – Genie Curtiss, From the time of her admission to Children’s Hospital researchers had tried to keep her identity concealed, and it was around this time that they adopted the pseudonym Genie for her, referencing similarities between a genie coming out of a lamp without having a childhood and Genie’s sudden emergence into society past childhood.
We can never know, therefore, if Genie failed to develop skills in all areas including language because of her privation or because she was born with an underlying learning difficulty.
He became almost singularly fixated on his mother, despite their relentless arguments about her attempts to convince him to adopt a less rigid lifestyle, and treated all other relationships as secondary at best.
Little has been revealed of her circumstances since then.
Rhode Island International Film Festival. True they cannot be generalised to a wider population nor are they ethically replicable. Butler also claimed that, shortly after moving in with her, Genie had become noticeably more talkative and that she had made substantial progress with her language acquisition.
At the privaiton of 11 months, Genie was still thd overall good health and had no noted mental abnormalities, but had fallen to the 11th percentile for weight.
During Genie’s stay, Butler had the man she was dating move in with her, believing that authorities would view her pending foster application more favorably if she offered a two-parent home. Several books about feral or abused children contain chapters on Genie, and many books on linguistics and psychology also discuss Genie’s case at length.
Soon after moving in with Butler, Genie started showing the first signs of reaching pubertymarking a dramatic improvement in her overall physical health and definitively putting her past Lenneberg’s proposed stuudy period for language acquisition.
It was dismissed by the Superior Court of the State of California ‘ with prejudice ,’ meaning that because it was without substance it can never again be refiled. The environment in Genie’s new placement was extremely rigid and gave her far less access to her favorite objects and activities, and her caretakers rarely allowed her mother to visit. Since the publication of Curtiss’ findings, her arguments have become widely accepted in the field of linguistics. She seemed especially curious about unfamiliar sounds, and Kent noted how intently she searched for their sources.
I think that case studies could be improved if the studies were able to be replicated, so that the study is still insightful and detailed but also more researchers could study whether the results could then be generalised. When they were discovered they had very little speech dtudy communicated mostly in gestures. Upon moving, Genie’s father increasingly confined Genie to the second bedroom in the back of the house while the rest of the family slept in the living room.
I agree that case studies have both many strengths and privagion, some of which affect its validity. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. In contrast to her linguistic abilities, Genie’s nonverbal communication continued to excel.
Case studies in psychological research. | daniellaking
Archived from the original on September 14, It may well be that the children selected for adoption were more emotionally stable and sociable than the ones reunited with their natural parents, and this individual difference in temperament could account for them forming closer relationships with their adopted parents. Extreme Social Isolation of a Child. She continued to have a very difficult time controlling her impulses, frequently engaging in highly anti-social and destructive behavior.
She was discovered age 13 when her mother left her husband and took Genie with her. Genie was studied at length by the researchers who adopted her, and she formed a degree of attachment to them. In the book, he suggested that Bowlby may have oversimplified the concept of maternal deprivation.
The research team considered her language acquisition to be a substantial part of their larger goal of helping her to integrate herself into society, so although they wanted to observe what vocabulary and grammar Genie could learn on her own, out of a sense of obligation they sometimes stepped in to assist her.
However it could be argued that they treated her unethically by using her as a research subject instead of simply giving her the love and caring she needed. Download this article as a PDF. Curtiss began thorough, active testing of Genie’s language in Octoberwhen she and Fromkin decided that her linguistic abilities were sufficient to yield usable results.